1,205+ Google Reviews - 4.8 Stars 

Geothermal Performance Pitfalls

Geothermal Toledo, OH Maumee, OH Holland, OH Sylvania, OH Rossford, OH Perrysburg, OH Swanton, OH Monclova, OH Whitehouse, OH Waterville, OH Erie, MI Temperance, MI Lambertville, MI Ottawa Lake, MI Ann Arbor, MI Saline, MI Ypsilanti, MI Monroe, MI

Unraveling the Complexities of Poor Geothermal System Performance

Geothermal systems are hailed for their efficiency and sustainability, promising long-term benefits in both residential and commercial HVAC applications. However, these systems are not without their challenges. While earlier discussions have pinpointed the use of shallow horizontal loops and improper system sizing as primary culprits for poor performance, there are additional factors that deserve scrutiny. This article aims to delve deeper into these issues.

Key Reasons for Poor Performance

Reason 1: Use of Shallow Horizontal Loops

Geothermal - woes of horizontal loops

The Underlying Issue and Seasonal Woes

Shallow horizontal loops are often favored for their economical installation costs. However, this upfront saving masks some inherent drawbacks. One of the most significant is the sensitivity of these shallow loops to fluctuating ground temperatures. Unlike deeper underground layers, the temperature at shallow depths is much more susceptible to seasonal changes.

During cold winters, this becomes particularly problematic. When the ground freezes, the shallow loops may not be able to extract sufficient heat to maintain a comfortable indoor environment. As a result, the system has to work overtime, leveraging backup heating methods or increasing the compressor’s duty cycle, which leads to high operational costs and reduced lifespan of the unit.

Impact on Efficiency Metrics

This increase in operational complexity negatively impacts the system’s Coefficient of Performance (COP). Where a well-designed geothermal system might typically operate at a COP of 4-5, shallow loop systems may see this figure dip to as low as 2-3 in harsh conditions, essentially halving its energy efficiency.

Soil Conductivity: The Unseen Variable

Shallow horizontal loops are also more susceptible to the variability in soil thermal conductivity. The soil type can significantly influence how efficiently heat is transferred between the loop and the earth, a variable often neglected during the design phase for shallow installations.

  • Depth Augmentation: If horizontal loops are non-negotiable due to space or other constraints, increasing their depth may offer some benefits, although this is often a compromise rather than an ideal solution.
  • Enhanced Thermal Grouts: Using thermal grouts with higher thermal conductivity can help in optimizing the heat exchange efficiency, though this doesn’t fully mitigate the shortcomings of shallow loops.

Why Vertical Loops Offer Better Performance

Depth-Enabled Stability

Geothermal - Vertical Loops

Vertical loops plunge much deeper into the Earth, tapping into a more stable thermal environment that isn’t subject to the whims of seasonal changes. This stability ensures a more consistent heat exchange process, boosting the system’s COP.

Reduced Land Requirement

Vertical installations also require less land area than their horizontal counterparts. This allows for more flexibility in system design and can be particularly advantageous in residential settings where land is often at a premium.

Lower Lifecycle Costs

Although the upfront costs of vertical loops are higher, the total cost of ownership often ends up being lower due to increased efficiency and lower maintenance needs. There’s less wear and tear on the system components, and there’s rarely a need for supplemental heating, even in colder climates.

Adaptability to Soil Conditions

Vertical loops are less affected by soil thermal conductivity, making them more adaptable to different geological conditions. This flexibility often makes vertical loops a universally reliable choice, irrespective of local soil characteristics

Reason 2: Improper System Sizing

The Oversizing Trap: More Than Just a Simple Error

The notion that ‘bigger is better’ is a pervasive misunderstanding in the HVAC world, and geothermal systems are no exception. This misconception often stems from a precautionary mindset—installing a larger system as a buffer for extreme weather conditions or future property expansions. However, this overcompensation leads to a myriad of problems that extend far beyond just wasted energy.

When a system is oversized, it tends to go through frequent ‘short-cycling,’ turning on and off rapidly because it reaches the set temperatures too quickly. This constant cycling not only shortens the lifespan of system components like compressors and fans but also results in inconsistent indoor temperatures and humidity levels. The latter is particularly concerning, as increased humidity can lead to issues like mold growth and decreased indoor air quality.

The Financial Toll

The financial ramifications of this mistake are also non-trivial. Oversized systems cost more upfront, and the increased wear and tear lead to higher maintenance expenses. Moreover, the energy inefficiency directly translates to steeper utility bills. All these costs accumulate over time, making the total cost of ownership significantly higher than it would be for a properly sized system.

  • Software-Assisted Load Calculations: Gone are the days of “rule of thumb” calculations for system sizing. Today’s sophisticated load calculation software incorporates variables like building insulation, window size, and even local weather patterns to provide a highly accurate thermal load calculation. This data-driven approach allows for tailored system sizing, ensuring that the unit neither underperforms nor wastes energy.
  • Adaptive Technologies: Modern geothermal systems can come equipped with smart technologies like modulating valves and variable-speed compressors. These components adjust in real-time according to the load requirements, thereby effectively countering the problems that come with improper sizing. In essence, they allow the system to operate at partial capacity when full power isn’t needed, enhancing efficiency and extending equipment life.

Reason 3: Poor Quality of Installation

Substandard Workmanship: The Silent Performance Eroder

It is easy to underestimate the impact of installation quality on the overall performance of a geothermal system. Like an iceberg, while the visible components might seem straightforward, a significant portion of the system’s intricacies lie beneath the surface. Faulty installations can have wide-ranging implications, and the effects of these mistakes can ripple throughout the system’s lifespan.

For instance, improperly sealed connections can lead to leaks, causing the refrigerant or water mixture to escape. This not only compromises the heat exchange efficiency but also risks contaminating the ground. Misaligned components can cause undue strain on parts, leading to premature wear and tear. These seemingly minor oversights drastically decrease the system’s efficiency, increase its operational costs, and can result in frequent, often expensive, maintenance interventions.

The Real-World Consequences

A poorly installed geothermal system can also impact the comfort levels within a building. Improper connections or misconfigurations can lead to uneven heating or cooling, creating zones of discomfort. Moreover, such issues can also escalate to become safety hazards, especially if electrical components are not installed correctly.

  • Certified Installers: The expertise of the installation professional is paramount. It’s essential to ensure that the professionals employed are certified specifically for geothermal installations. These certifications are an assurance that the installer has been trained to understand the nuances and best practices of geothermal systems.
  • Quality Audits: Implementing regular quality checks and audits is not just a proactive measure but a necessary one. By routinely inspecting installations, one can identify potential issues before they escalate, ensuring that installation standards are consistently met. This proactive approach also acts as a deterrent, ensuring that installers remain meticulous in their work.
  • Ongoing Training: The HVAC and geothermal industry is continuously evolving, with new techniques, tools, and best practices emerging. It’s vital that installation professionals stay updated with these changes. Regular workshops and training sessions can ensure that your team is always at the forefront of installation best practices.
  • Feedback Mechanism: Encouraging feedback from customers post-installation can provide invaluable insights into potential issues or areas of improvement. This feedback loop can serve as an early warning system for any recurrent installation problems.

Reason 4: Inadequate Maintenance

The Snowball Effect: The Silent Degradation

Every mechanical system, regardless of its sophistication or build quality, is susceptible to wear and tear. Over time, even minor issues can accumulate and evolve into major challenges if left unchecked. This is particularly true for geothermal systems, where the performance is closely tied to the system’s efficiency, and even marginal degradations can lead to pronounced inefficiencies.

Inadequate maintenance can lead to issues like sediment build-up in the loop, compressor fatigue, or even software glitches in modern systems with digital components. When these issues compound, the system has to work harder to produce the same output, leading to reduced efficiency. This not only translates to higher energy bills but also stresses the system components further, shortening their effective lifespan.

The Domino Effect

As issues accumulate, they don’t just stay isolated. One problem can lead to another in a cascading manner. For example, a clogged loop can strain the compressor, which in turn might cause overheating and impact other components. Before you know it, what began as a small maintenance oversight has escalated into a significant repair or even a full system replacement.

  • Scheduled Maintenance: Being reactive in maintenance is a recipe for disaster. Proactive, scheduled maintenance check-ups are crucial. These regular inspections should encompass every part of the system—from loop inspections ensuring there’s no sediment build-up or leaks, to compressor performance assessments ensuring it’s working at optimal efficiency. Scheduled maintenance acts as the first line of defense against potential issues, catching them before they become substantial problems.
  • Advanced Monitoring Systems: In today’s digital age, relying solely on manual inspections is outdated. Smart monitoring systems equipped with sensors and analytics can offer invaluable insights into a geothermal system’s performance. These systems provide real-time performance metrics, allowing for a deep dive into any inefficiencies. More importantly, they can preemptively notify when maintenance is due or if they detect anomalies, ensuring that issues are addressed promptly.
  • Employee Training: It’s not enough to have the best tools if the personnel isn’t trained to use them effectively. Regular training sessions for maintenance staff can ensure that they’re updated with the latest techniques, tools, and best practices in geothermal system upkeep.
  • Documentation: Keeping detailed records of all maintenance activities can provide insights into patterns or recurring issues. These records can be invaluable, especially when troubleshooting complex problems or planning preventive measures for known recurring issues.

Reason 5: Water Quality Issues

The Silent Erosion: Destructive Force from Within

While the notion of water causing damage seems counterintuitive, especially in systems designed to circulate it, the quality of this water or antifreeze solution is paramount to the longevity and efficiency of geothermal systems. The intricacies of these systems mean that even minor imbalances in water chemistry can have a domino effect on performance and component longevity.

Water quality issues can be insidious. Over time, mineral-laden water can cause scaling on heat exchanger surfaces, reducing their efficiency. Similarly, the pH levels of the circulating solution, if not balanced, can accelerate corrosion, compromising the integrity of the system’s piping and other components. Moreover, if left unchecked, biofouling can occur, which involves the growth of microorganisms in the system that can further obstruct flow and hinder heat transfer.

The Hidden Impact

The effects of water quality issues are multifaceted. While immediate problems like reduced efficiency or blockages are apparent, there’s also the long-term degradation of system components. This degradation can lead to frequent maintenance needs, premature replacements, and, in worst-case scenarios, system failures.

Furthermore, as the system struggles against these challenges, it consumes more energy to achieve the desired output, leading to escalating energy bills.

  • Water Treatment Plans: Regular monitoring of water quality is essential. By consistently checking the pH, hardness, and other pertinent parameters of the circulating fluid, imbalances can be detected early. Depending on the results, specific treatment plans can be implemented. This could range from simple pH adjustments to more comprehensive treatments to combat issues like scaling or biofouling.
  • Material Selection: In geothermal systems, the adage “an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure” rings especially true. Opting for materials known for their corrosion resistance can prove invaluable in the long run. Stainless steel, certain plastics, and other specially treated materials can resist the detrimental effects of water quality issues, ensuring that the system remains functional and efficient for a more extended period.
  • Loop Fluid Enhancements: Using additives in the circulating fluid can be a preventive measure against scaling, corrosion, and biofouling. These additives, which must be chosen based on compatibility with the system and fluid type, act as inhibitors, reducing the potential for such issues to arise.
  • Continuous Education: Keeping abreast of the latest research and best practices in water treatment can provide insights into newer, more effective solutions. As geothermal technology advances, so too do the methods to maintain and optimize them. Regular training or consultation with experts in the field can ensure that you’re always employing the most effective water treatment strategies.

Final Thoughts

The effectiveness and longevity of a geothermal system hinge upon a harmonious synthesis of its design, technology, installation, and maintenance. Understanding the nuances of loop configurations is essential, especially in challenging environments. Concurrently, properly sizing the system using advanced tools and technologies ensures optimal efficiency and cost-effectiveness. However, beyond these technicalities, the quality of the installation remains paramount, setting the foundation for the system’s overall performance. As we venture deeper into the system’s life cycle, regular maintenance emerges as the linchpin, safeguarding the system from avoidable malfunctions and costly interventions. Lastly, the silent yet critical aspect of water quality can’t be understated; its management directly correlates with the system’s health and lifespan. By addressing each of these facets with diligence and expertise, a geothermal system can truly be a sustainable, efficient, and long-lasting energy solution.

Read more on Geothermal Here:

About Fry Heating & Cooling: A fully licensed and certified contractor in the Heating, Cooling, and Plumbing industry, ardently adheres to a Christ-centric organizational philosophy. Our faith-based foundation guides us in every aspect of our operations, driving us to serve our regional market with dedication, compassion, and integrity. We are steadfast in our commitment to providing Fast, Friendly, and Fair services to all our clients, ensuring prompt responsiveness, exceptional customer engagement, and equitable pricing. Our standards of professionalism and goodwill reflect our aspiration to honor our faith in our daily conduct, while exceeding the expectations of our customers.

At Fry Heating & Cooling, our team of certified technicians specializes in a comprehensive range of HVAC, plumbing, and commercial RTU services, including installation, repair, and maintenance of air conditioning systems, furnaces, heat pumps, indoor air quality products, plumbing systems, commercial rooftop units and generators. With a legacy of excellence and a commitment to customer satisfaction, we are your one-stop solution for all your indoor comfort needs.

Fry Heating & Cooling is proud to service the top 10 residential HVAC OEMs delivering unparalleled customer satisfaction and industry-leading expertise. As a premier HVAC contractor, we specialize in servicing and installing top-rated brands such as CarrierTrane, Lennox, Goodman, RheemYork, Daikin, American Standard, Bryant, and Amana. 

Want to receive the latest news, tips, and encouragement? 

Fill out the form below to signup to our weekly newsletter.  


* indicates required
Air Conditioning

Spring into Action

Your Ultimate Guide to AC Readiness With the arrival of spring, the warmth and beauty of the season bring a gentle reminder: it’s time to

Read More »
air purification Toledo, OH Maumee, OH Holland, OH Sylvania, OH Rossford, OH Perrysburg, OH Swanton, OH Monclova, OH Whitehouse, OH Waterville, OH Erie, MI Temperance, MI Lambertville, MI Ottawa Lake, MI Ann Arbor, MI Saline, MI Ypsilanti, MI Monroe, MI
Air Quality

Air Purification

Breathing New Life into Air Purification: The Reme Halo Solution and the Power of Indoor Plants In today’s world, where indoor air quality is a

Read More »
Heat Pump Cold Weather
Heat Pump

New Heat Pumps

New Heat Pumps: Revolutionizing Comfort in Cold Weather Heat pumps have been a game-changer in home heating and cooling systems, and recent advancements have significantly

Read More »
Furnace Maintenance

Furnace Maintenance

Furnace Maintenance: Keeping Your Home and Business Warm and Efficient Once upon a chilly winter, a homeowner discovered that her furnace was not heating as

Read More »
HVAC Financing Toledo, OH Maumee, OH Holland, OH Sylvania, OH Rossford, OH Perrysburg, OH Swanton, OH Monclova, OH Whitehouse, OH Waterville, OH Erie, MI Temperance, MI Lambertville, MI Ottawa Lake, MI Ann Arbor, MI Saline, MI Ypsilanti, MI Monroe, MI

HVAC Financing

HVAC Financing: 6 Steps to Smart Borrowing Unmasking the Appeal of Low APR Financing The genuine cost of financing HVAC systems is not solely contained

Read More »

Call or Text us

Michigan 734-203-0347

New Installation